green book Archives - Examining the World Mission Society Church of God An in depth look at the World Mission Society Church of God Fri, 12 Aug 2022 23:56:28 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/ex-content/uploads/2020/03/cropped-Examining-updated-favicon-32x32.png green book Archives - Examining the World Mission Society Church of God 32 32 Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent – Why Was It šŸ—‘ļø Deleted? https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/chapter-36-elijah-will-be-sent-why-was-it-deleted/ https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/chapter-36-elijah-will-be-sent-why-was-it-deleted/#comments Fri, 17 Apr 2020 22:26:44 +0000 https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/?p=126721 By LearningLark - https://www.flickr.com/photos/44282411@N04/4141069138/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32735438The World Mission Society Church of God deleted three chapters from The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (1980), written by Ahn Sahng Hong, a man the WMSCOGā€™s claims was God (All 3 chapters are available here). In this article we will examine the likely reasons why the WMSCOG chose to delete Chapter […]]]> By LearningLark - https://www.flickr.com/photos/44282411@N04/4141069138/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32735438
By LearningLark - https://www.flickr.com/photos/44282411@N04/4141069138/, CC BY 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32735438

The World Mission Society Church of God deleted three chapters from The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (1980), written by Ahn Sahng Hong, a man the WMSCOGā€™s claims was God (All 3 chapters are available here). In this article we will examine the likely reasons why the WMSCOG chose to delete Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent.

Who was Elijah according to the WMSCOG?

According to the WMSCOG, Ahn Sahng Hong came as Elijah’s to testify about Zahng Gil Jah being “god the mother.” There is no proof of this claim, except for a few written notes from the preface of a book alleged to have been written by Ahn Sahng Hong, that the WMSCOG does not make available for even their members to read.

What was Elijah’s mission according to Ahn Sahng Hong?

However, the last prophet Elijah was the one to convey the last truth of preparing the way for the Second Coming of Jesus. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

According to Ahn Sahng Hong, the last Elijah was to prepare the way for the Second Coming of Jesus, not a “god the mother.” In fact, there is no mention of a female god anywhere in the above referenced book, though Ahn Sahng Hong did write a book denouncing the idea of a “mother god” in 1983.

Was Ahn Sahng Hong Elijah, the Second Coming of Jesus or Both?

The World Mission Society Church of God teaches that Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah and the Second Coming of Jesus Christ. Yet, Ahn Sahng Hong wrote that Elijah was to prepare the way for the Second Coming of Jesus, so could he be both? Would God need to return to prepare the way for Himself? The concept of God preparing the way for Himself would nullify the purpose of John the Baptist preparing the way for Jesus at His first coming.

Therefore, when the day of the Second Coming of Jesus nears, He will first send Elijah the Prophet and who would testify fully as if one is seeing the First Coming of Jesus, and He will thereafter return. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

Ahn Sahng Hong very clearly wrote that Elijah would be sent first to testify about the Second Coming of Jesus, and not until after, would Jesus return. Therefore, if Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah, then who was Jesus that came after? In the alternative, if Ahn Sahng Hong was the Second Coming of Jesus, then who was Elijah that prepared the way for him?

Because the first, actual Elijah had ascended when he was alive (2 Kings 2:11), the last Elijahā€™s mission is to transform and ascend while he is alive. The last Elijahā€™s mission is to transform and ascend along with the live 144,000 saints. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

Even if you were to believe that Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah and Jesus, the last mission that Ahn Sahng Hong wrote about did not materialize. According to Ahn Sahng Hong, Elijah is to transform and ascend while alive, meaning that the last Elijah is not supposed to die. Despite this, Ahn Sahng Hong died in 1985 of a stroke and is buried alongside his real wife Hwang Won Soon.

Ahn Sahng Hong also wrote that Elijah is to transform and ascend alive along with the 144,000 saints. Ahn Sahng Hong did not ascend with 144,000 saints, and remains buried six feet underground in South Korea. In contradiction, The World Mission Society Church of God teaches that Zahng Gil Jah will not die and she will ascend with the 144,000 saints when the world ends. We will have to wait and see if that happens.

Why would “God” cite an SDA “prophetess” as a source for credibility?

Ellen G. White had also written about the last Elijah as follows: ā€œElijah was the symbol of saints who would be alive at the time of the return of Christ.ā€ (God of Prophecy Pā€¢K227) – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

Ahn Sahng Hong relies on writings by Ellen G. White, considered a prophetess by the Seventh Day Adventist Church, in order to support his exhortation on the matter of Elijah. Jesus, or God, would not need to rely on the writings of a so-called “prophetess” to support the claim that Elijah would be alive at the time of Jesus’ return.

Did Ahn Sahng Hong believe he was living in the end times?

What does the history at that time of John the Baptist tell us today? The past is not all gone, but the fulfillment of the prophecy of the past now lies before us. All that history must manifest today, the end of mankind. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

It has been documented by a South Korean Court and elsewhere, that Ahn Sahng Hong made numerous false doomsday predictions. This is supported by his writings not only in Chapter 36 of the above referenced book, but in Chapter 1 as well (more on Chapter 1 and why it was deleted coming soon). It is obvious that Ahn Sahng Hong believed that the end of the world was imminent when he wrote his book in 1980, but it has been 40 years since then and the world has not ended.

But the prophet who presumes to speak a word in my name that I have not commanded him to speak, or who speaks in the name of other gods, that same prophet shall die.ā€™ And if you say in your heart, ā€˜How may we know the word that the Lord has not spoken?ā€™ā€” when a prophet speaks in the name of the Lord, if the word does not come to pass or come true, that is a word that the Lord has not spoken; the prophet has spoken it presumptuously. You need not be afraid of him.

Deuteronomy 18:20-22

The final Elijah would come to an end by finding and testifying all the truth that had been trampled during the dark ages. That Elijah (God Jehovah), as the final judge, along with the 144,000 saints will be transformed into angels and ascended. Malachi the prophet said that Elijah the prophet will be sent last. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

When discussing the last Elijah, Ahn Sahng Hong describes events referenced in Revelation 7 that ultimately did not take place. If you are to believe that Ahn Sahng Hong was God and Elijah, then Ahn Sahng Hong should have ascended alive along with the 144,000 saints instead of dying in 1985.

Ahn Sahng Hong’s Grave

What is the meaning of the name Elijah according to Ahn Sahng Hong?

When the name ā€œElijahā€ is translated, it means ā€œJehovah is my Godā€…Thereby, ā€œEliā€ means ā€œGodā€ and ā€œJahā€ has its root in Hebrew ā€œYahwehā€ – that is, Jehovah.
It symbolizes God in flesh and blood. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

Elijah, from the Hebrew name ×Ö±×œÖ“יÖøּהוּ (‘Eliyyahu) meaning “my God is YAHWEH“, is derived from the elements אֵל (‘el) and יÖøה (yah), both referring to the Hebrew God. Ahn Sahng Hong’s claim that this translation ultimately “symbolizes God in flesh and blood” is a non sequitur and grossly misleading. There is nothing in the translation to suggest that the name Elijah has anything to do with God’s flesh and blood.

On the other hand, it is reasonable to conclude that Jesus represented God’s (Jehovah) flesh and blood because he was God’s Son who was born in the flesh, not because of the simple translation of a name. (Jesus’ Hebrew name was Yeshua. The Hebrew name Yeshua, which is based on the Semitic root y-Å”-Ź• (Hebrew: ישעā€Ž), means “to deliver” or “to rescue.”)

Elijah AND Melchizedek without genealogy?

Historically, Elijah does not have a father, mother, genealogy, beginning of days, nor end of life then ascends to heaven; similar to the ancient Melchizedek…Elijahā€™s situation is similar to the one of Melchizedekā€™s. Most of the people recorded in the
Bible have their parentsā€™ names or genealogy identified, but Elijah and Melchizedekā€™s parental names, genealogy, and their day of their beginning and end are not identified.
The final Elijah would come to an end by finding and testifying all the truth that had been trampled during the dark ages. That Elijah (God Jehovah), as the final judge, along with the 144,000 saints will be transformed into angels and ascended. Malachi the prophet said that Elijah the prophet will be sent last. – Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

Ahn Sahng Hong

In the above quote, which are the last lines of Chapter 36, Ahn Sahng Hong seems to suggest that Elijah would come as a prophet to reveal God in the flesh, the Second Coming of Jesus specifically. Instead, the World Mission Society Church of God teaches that Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah but does not emphasize that Elijah was also without genealogy. The WMSCOG chooses to teach that Ahn Sahng Hong “fulfilled the prophecy of Melchizedek,” because Ahn Sahng Hong draws a clear connection between Melchizedek and Jesus in Chapter 17 of the redacted version of The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (Hebrews 5:8-10). Ahn Sahng Hong also implies a connection between Melchizedek, Jesus and the Old Testament law of tithing (citing Genesis 14:20). This serves to reinforce the WMSCOG’s claim that tithing is required for salvation. It is also important to note that tithing is a measure of faith and is required in order to move up within the organization.

Was Ahn Sahng Hong Elijah, Melchizedek, Jesus and Jehovah?

It would appear that Ahn Sahng Hong suggests a connection between Elijah, Melchizedek, Jesus and Jehovah throughout his book. But there are important points to consider here:

  1. Ahn Sahng Hong believed that the last Elijah was to prepare the way for the Second Coming of Jesus;
  2. If Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah, he did not fulfill his own prophecy about Elijah ascending and transforming alive along with the 144,000 saints;
  3. The world did not end during Ahn Sahng Hong’s lifetime, as he believed it would; and most importantly
  4. Ahn Sahng Hong did not claim that Elijah was to prepare the way for a “mother god.” Ahn Sahng Hong rejected Um Soo In’s claim that he was Isaac (and therefore Jesus). Ahn Sahng Hong also rejected the idea that the New Jerusalem in Galations 4:26 represented “a mother god” because that would mean that Isaac, or Jesus, would be married to his mother.

Therefore, not only are Ahn Sahng Hongs teachings unreliable because his predictions did not come true, taken within the context of his other books, the idea that Ahn Sahng Hong in any way believed in a “god the mother” simply does not fit. If this deleted chapter supported the World Mission Society Church of God’s argument that Ahn Sahng Hong prepared the way for Zahng Gil Jah, why did they delete it from his book?

Why does the WMSCOG hide this chapter from its members?

Chapter 36 of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book would have cause major problems for the World Mission Society Church of God if they had not deleted it from future editions. This chapter would expose the following key contradictions:

Ahn Sahng HongThe WMSCOG
The last Elijah’s mission was to prepare the way for the Second Coming of Jesus.Elijah’s mission was to prepare the way for Zahng Gil Jah and reveal her as “god the mother.”
Elijah was to come before the Second Coming of Jesus.Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah and the Second Coming of Jesus.
The last Elijah will not die.Ahn Sahng Hong was Elijah. Ahn Sahng Hong died but Zahng Gil Jah will not die.
Elijah will ascend and transform alive, along with the 144,000 saints. Zahng Gil Jah will ascend along with 144,000 saints who she will save from the last disaster.

The amount of discrepancies between Ahn Sahng Hong’s teachings and the teachings of the World Mission Society Church of God, continue to increase exponentially as we discover more of Ahn Sahng Hong’s original books. The amount of control that the WMSCOG must have over members who become aware of their numerous lies by omission, but do not decide to leave this cult immediately, is incomprehensible.

Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent, by Ahn Sahng Hong

Green-Book-Chapter-36

]]>
https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/chapter-36-elijah-will-be-sent-why-was-it-deleted/feed/ 2
The WMSCOG Removed 3 Chapters From Ahn Sahng Hong’s Book https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/the-wmscog-removed-3-chapters-from-ahn-sahng-hongs-book/ https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/the-wmscog-removed-3-chapters-from-ahn-sahng-hongs-book/#comments Thu, 09 Apr 2020 00:01:35 +0000 https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/?p=126641 The World Mission Society Church of God believes that Ahn Sahng Hong was the Second Coming of Jesus. The Bible clearly says, so does the World Mission Society Church of God for that matter, do not add or take away from the Bible (Revelation 22:19).  Yet, the WMSCOG deleted three chapters from The Mystery of God […]]]>

The World Mission Society Church of God believes that Ahn Sahng Hong was the Second Coming of Jesus. The Bible clearly says, so does the World Mission Society Church of God for that matter, do not add or take away from the Bible (Revelation 22:19).  Yet, the WMSCOG deleted three chapters from The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life (1980), by Ahn Sahng Hong, a man the WMSCOG’s claims was God. The 1980 version has 38 chapters, while the 2007 Korean/English version of the book has 35 chapters. This is not the first time we see the WMSCOG making critical edits to Ahn Sahng Hong’s writings. Why would the WMSCOG delete entire chapters from a book written by someone they believe was God?

The names of the missing chapters are:

  • Chapter 1: Restoration of Jerusalem and the Prophecy of 40 Years (On page 3 below, Ahn Sahng Hong predicted that the world would end in 1988).
  • Chapter 11: Let Us Reveal the Truth from the History Books About the Church
  • Chapter 36: Elijah Will Be Sent

All three chapters are available below. They are available in Korean here and here. Articles about the possible reasons why these chapters were removed and the obvious contradictions between what Ahn Sahng Hong wrote in these chapters and what the World Mission Society Church of God teaches, will be posted over the next few weeks.

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com] Three-Missing-Chapters

]]>
https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/the-wmscog-removed-3-chapters-from-ahn-sahng-hongs-book/feed/ 1
Changes in the Green Book – Part 2 – Removal of “40 years” References https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-2-removal-of-40-years-references/ https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-2-removal-of-40-years-references/#comments Wed, 30 May 2012 04:51:25 +0000 https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/?p=4365 Update 2020:Ā  It turns out that the WMSCOG deleted three entire chapters from the original version of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book and it turns out that he believed the world would end in 1988. This article is dedicated to a man whose wife doesn’t live with him because of disagreements over WMSCOG involvement.  May she […]]]>

Update 2020:Ā  It turns out that the WMSCOG deleted three entire chapters from the original version of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book and it turns out that he believed the world would end in 1988.

This article is dedicated to a man whose wife doesn’t live with him because of disagreements over WMSCOG involvement.  May she come home soon.

“The Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life,” or better known as “The Green Book”, is a book read in the WMSCOG written by Ahn Sahng Hong, a man they incorrectly claim to be the Second Coming of Jesus Christ.  Since Ahn Sahng Hong is their false god, this book effectively serves as an addendum to Holy Scripture, much like the Book of Mormon.

 

God’s Book Changing?

So if God writes a book, do you think that book should change over time? It’s reasonable to have minor translation differences between languages, but what if the changes were not simply translation differences? What if they removed certain paragraphs entirely?  What if those paragraphs that were removed just happened to testify against what they teach now?

When we compare a 1993 edition of the 1967 Green Book to the Green Book in 2000, we find some curious changes:

Ahn Sahng Hong Falsely Predicted the End of World

What is clear is that Ahn Sahng Hong predicted the end of the world within 40 years in his 1967 writing.  This is a 1993 edition of the 1967 book according to the publisher’s information.  Ahn Sahng Hong, apparently writing in 1967, even explicitly states that he believes Matthew 24:31-34 refers to the “last one generation”:

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

Ahn Sahng Hong’s False Predictions Removed From His Writings

However, in a copy of the Green Book from 2000 we find Ahn Sahng Hong’s predictions about the end of the world have been removed:

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

It’s interesting to note the parts of the book which were removed were the ones that did not come true.

A False Prophet’s Changing Words

The world did not end within 40 years of Ahn Sahng Hong’s prophecy, and those prophecies subsequently disappeared from his writings in the Green Book read in the WMSCOG.

  • Paragraph 3 last line removed – “This word is about the last one generation.”
  • Paragraph 4 removed completely:  “Therefore it is the Last Church that will be changed alive and go up to heaven.  So the last secret, unsealing of the seven thunders cannot be in the church established more than 40 years ago.”
  • Paragraph 5 last line removed:  “So this Last Church should be ended up within 40 years.”

Here are the books side by side for comparison, or you can jump to a high-resolution version here (473 KB)

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

View or download the high resolution version here (473 KB)

To those who believe in Ahn Sahng Hong–any explanation is good enough, to those who do not–no explanation is necessary.

]]>
https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-2-removal-of-40-years-references/feed/ 14
Changes in the Green Book – Part 1 – Removal of “Second Coming” References https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-1-removal-of-second-coming-references/ https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-1-removal-of-second-coming-references/#comments Sat, 26 May 2012 22:37:24 +0000 https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/?p=4375 Update 2020:Ā  It turns out that the WMSCOG deleted three entire chapters from the original version of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book and it turns out that he believed the world would end in 1988. This article is dedicated to a man whose brother spends hot days out preaching in a suit. May he come home […]]]>

Update 2020:Ā  It turns out that the WMSCOG deleted three entire chapters from the original version of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book and it turns out that he believed the world would end in 1988.

This article is dedicated to a man whose brother spends hot days out preaching in a suit. May he come home soon.

 

The “Mystery of God and the Spring of the Water of Life,” or better known as “The Green Book”, is a book read in the WMSCOG written by Ahn Sahng Hong, a man they incorrectly claim to be the Second Coming of Jesus Christ.  Since Ahn Sahng Hong is their false god, this book effectively serves as an addendum to Holy Scripture, much like the Book of Mormon.

       

God’s Book Changing?

So if God writes a book, do you think that book should change over time? It’s reasonable to have minor translation differences between languages, but what if the changes were not simply translation differences? What if they changed the meaning entirely?

When we compare the Green Book in 1993 to the Green Book in 2010, we find some curious changes.

The “Second Coming Jesus” Writes About the Future “Second Coming Jesus”?

Just to be clear, Ahn Sahng Hong never claimed anywhere in his writings to be Jesus Christ. Rather, it is the WMSCOG which claims he was the Second Coming of Jesus. Yet, we find that Ahn Sahng Hong in the 1993 version of his book, speaks about the future Second Coming of Jesus:

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

In the 2010 edition though, this language has been altered. The words “future” and “Second” have been removed. It’s curious that these words which seem to go against the WMSCOG’s claim that Ahn Sahng Hong was the Second Coming of Jesus Christ were the ones removed:

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

Ahn Sahng Hong clearly states in 1993 version of the book, that the Second Coming of Jesus will be in the future.  This fits in line with the understanding that he believed himself to be the Prophet Elijah heralding in the last days and announcing the imminent return of the Second Coming of Jesus.  After all, that’s what his tombstone says.  You can see the books side by side below, or if you want to jump to a high resolution version click here (1.1 MB) :

[See image gallery at www.examiningthewmscog.com]

View or download the high res version here (1.1 MB)

Update 2020:  It turns out that the WMSCOG deleted three entire chapters from the original version of Ahn Sahng Hong’s book and it turns out that he believed the world would end in 1988.

]]>
https://www.examiningthewmscog.com/changes-in-the-green-book-part-1-removal-of-second-coming-references/feed/ 29