- Topic
On the surface this video presents some compelling arguments, each discussed one at a time:
That what happened in the past will happen again – Ecclesiastes 1:9
While this may be appealing if I were a member interested in the mysteries of the prophecies, there could be two sides to this.
One: the creator of the video presents that people will deny Christ. The author presents this argument well. However,
The second side of the story is the influence that the Pharisees had, and the author even states (at 1:55):
“The unbelief of most was influenced by the religious leaders at that time. They were known as the Pharisees or Teachers of the Law.” Reference: YouTube user The True WMSCOG https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uxHyZTELyFk
This begs the question, how did the Pharisees influence the general membership?
Two: it is interesting that the video creator quotes John 12:37-43 (at 2:15) “…but because of the Pharisees they would not confess their faith for fear they would be put out of the synagogue;”
Certainly then, ostracism was a tool used by the Pharisees to maintain social control. At the very least, evidence points in that direction, no?
At this stage of the video a transition takes place. The foundation has been set that Pharisees are:
Influencial
Either unaware of their own flawed thinking, or
are totally bought-in to their own ideology
Word-twisters
At 3:50 it is discussed how Jesus was taken to the “Chief priests and the whole Sanhedrin where they were looking for evidence against Jesus so that they could put him to death”.
A revisit to Ecclesiastes 1:9, “what happened in the past will happen again”….that when a group of people assemble – all of the same general opinion to start with – will come to a foregone conclusion to get what they want, which in this case was to silence Jesus. And permanently – he was a threat to the system in place that the Pharisees were in charge of. Right on, YouTube user The True WMSCOG!
At 4:34 it is discussed how taking words out of context changed and influenced the audience at hand to such a degree that they put a pure and innocent man to death. Right on, again! That is some kind of influence.
“now if you had lived in the time of Jesus and believed the testimony of the Pharisees, then you would have called Jesus a blasphemer and would have accused him of being demon-possessed” (at 5:08). This is a powerful concept brought to us by YouTube user The True WMSCOG. That if leaders have these powers:
Kicking out followers, as documented in the video – by their fear they did not speak due to threat of ostracization
Bringing people together where all opinions are the same
Taking words and phrases out of context – only allowing one side to testify
Then we, also, would have followed the group.
It is presented that the Bible was not written by those that didn’t believe in Him, “there is no book in the Bible written by the viewpoint of the Pharisees”, “if there was a book in the Bible written by the Pharisees, then most people today would reject Jesus as the Savior”. (5:30-35 mark).
“THE REASON WE NEED TO KNOW THIS HISTORY IS BECAUSE THE SAME IS HAPPENING NOW””. (5:40 mark)
This begs the question, how do we know if we are acting like the Pharisees? How do we examine the world around us when our leaders run for president and people that oppose them are “horrible persons”? (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jp6qttQL-dA) . How do other “Pharisees” work? YouTube user The True WMSCOG talks about patterns:
At 6:15 it is presented that those speaking against “completely make up lies”. When those that speak out against an organization are all completely discredited, see here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6iDVIs6OAQQ. The pattern here is anyone from inside of that (other) organization would….be going back to their “Pharisees” for all of the answers….back to that circle of influence where all opinions are generally the same and that anyone that speaks or thinks differently gets kicked out either immediately or soon. Or, shuts up and falls back in line.
When we believe that we have found utopia, all criticism is then – by default – negative. But the Pharisees became influencial by word twisting. This can include the flawed logic of error by omission – the omission of another side of the story. After all, Pharisees being like lawyers only present their side of the case.
So yes, YouTube user The True WMSCOG, you do present a fairly good case of how people speaking against your group act like the Pharisees….but it is presented inside of the logic that favors you. Unfortunately, if ostracism is a factor present in your social group then we have to strike up a similarity with Pharisees on that one. Of course, I’m sure if your group did have the influence that the Pharisees had over their followers – we were reminded how the past will repeat – then followers would likely view it not as ostracism. And one sided presentations were an issue associated with Pharisees…I for one was told to cool it off and tone it down if my friendship was to remain. So we don’t talk about behaviors in common with Pharisees anymore. It never was about belief with my friend but he seemed to always go there.
At 6:26, “Now learning a lesson from the past, if you really want to learn and understand about the World Mission Society Church of God, Christ Ahnsahnghong and Heavenly Mother, Don’t ask the modern day Pharisees”
It makes sense on the surface but as for social controls, this last one closes the loop, and convincingly. The message becomes clear, “come to us for the answers”. Just consider: those of us with differing opinions are not asking nor requiring to take on our way of thinking. It is only being asked to consider the other side of the story. But then, how do you know that we are not little devils trying to deceive you – that we are justified to lie and deceive to promote our “side”, so we ask,
Do you have the right to tell little white lies? To perform acts of deception that are justified under the right circumstances?
How would that materially different?
With the answer to that question comes the answer to the question about us being little devils. (spoiler alert: it involves methods of social controls that keep people inside of a social circle……spoiler alert: Pharisee alert)
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.